February 14, 2007 - Scientists Elucidate the Origin of the Darkest Galaxies in the Universe - Press Release

This image from a supercomputer simulation shows as bright clumps the dark matter satellites that can be found around our Milky Way galaxy. The central region corresponds to that containing the luminous matter (gas and stars) of the Milky Way. (Click on image for larger version and complete caption.)

Menlo Park, CA—Ghostly galaxies composed almost entirely of dark matter speckle the universe. Unlike normal galaxies, these extreme systems contain very few stars and are almost devoid of gas. Most of the luminous matter, so common in most galaxies, has been stripped away, leaving behind a dark matter shadow. These intriguing galaxies—known as dwarf spheroidals—are so faint that, although researchers believe they exist throughout the universe, only those relatively close to Earth have ever been observed. And until recently, no scientific model proposed to unravel their origin could simultaneously explain their exceptional dark matter content and their penchant for existing only in close proximity to much larger galaxies.

Now, the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center's Stelios Kazantzidis, a researcher in Stanford University's Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology, in collaboration with Lucio Mayer of the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich and the University of Zurich, Chiara Mastropietro of the University of Munich in Germany, and James Wadsley of McMaster University in Canada, has developed an elegant explanation for how galaxies come to be dominated by dark matter. Kazantzidis, who completed part of the study as a Fellow in the University of Chicago's Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, reports his findings in the February 15 issue of Nature.

"These results are so exciting because they are based on a combination of physical effects that has never before been postulated," said Kazantzidis. "This is one step toward a more complete understanding of the formation of structure in the universe, which is one of the fundamental goals of astrophysics."

Using supercomputers to create novel simulations of galaxy formation, Kazantzidis and his collaborators found that a dark matter-dominated galaxy begins life as a normal system. But when it approaches a much more massive galaxy, it simultaneously encounters three environmental effects—"ram pressure," "tidal shocking" and the cosmic ultraviolet background—that transform it into a mere dark-matter shadow of its former self.

Stelios Kazantzidis. Image courtesy of Diana Rogers, SLAC. (Click on image for high resolution version.)

Simultaneously, as the satellite galaxy moved closer to the massive system, it encountered the overwhelming gravitational force of the much larger mass. This force wrenched luminous stars from the small galaxy. Over billions of years of evolution, the satellite passed by the massive galaxy several times as it traversed its orbital path. Each time its stars shook and the satellite lost some of them as a result of a mechanism called tidal shocking. These effects conspired to eventually strip away nearly all the luminous matter--gas and stars--and left behind only a dark-matter shadow of the original galaxy.

The dark matter, on the other hand, was nongaseous and therefore unaffected by the ram pressure force or the cosmic ultraviolet background, the scientists posit. It did experience tidal shocking, but this force alone was not strong enough to pull away a substantial amount of dark matter.

The numerical simulations conducted by Kazantzidis and his collaborators constitute the most extensive calculations ever performed on this topic, consuming up to two months of supercomputing time each at the University of Zurich, the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center and elsewhere.

"Computer models of galaxy formation in the last decade or so have focused on modeling the properties of dark matter rather than those of the more familiar baryonic [luminous] matter," said Mayer. "Instead, our work suggests that we cannot understand the origin of galaxies without modeling the detailed physics of baryonic matter, even in a dark matter dominated Universe."

The scientists say this new understanding of the origin of the darkest galaxies in the universe may soon lead to fundamental insights into the nature of dark matter.

The image at left shows the current distribution of dark matter in the Milky Way galaxy, with black boxes around dark matter dominated satellite galaxies. The multiple panels at right show the distribution of luminous matter in one of these satellites as it fell into the Milky Way about 10 billion years ago, according to Kazantzidis' model. All images are from supercomputer simulations. (Click on image for larger version and complete caption.)

Mystery of the missing satellites

Additionally, the work may help to explain a long-standing discrepancy between theory and observation. The leading modern cosmological model, Lambda Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM), predicts that many more small galaxies surround massive galaxies like the Milky Way and Andromeda than are currently observed. This mismatch, which is often referred to as the "missing satellites problem," has been traditionally regarded as one of the toughest challenges to the ΛCDM paradigm. Kazantzidis' work suggests that the process by which small galaxies are stripped of their luminous matter is common, and implies that the "missing" galaxies could exist in the form of dark-matter-dominated satellites.

"These galaxies could just be too dark to detect," he said. "But their possible existence will substantially alleviate the missing satellites problem with profound implications for the predictive power of the ΛCDM theory." Coincidentally, in the last few months, one of the most advanced observational programs ever undertaken, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, has revealed in the vicinity of the Milky Way a number of what appears to be ultra-faint satellite galaxies. If this finding is confirmed by follow-up observations and analysis, these newly discovered systems would be explained by Kazantzidis' calculations and would contribute to solving the long-standing missing satellites problem, he says.

This research has been supported by the Zwicky Prize Fellowship program at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich and by the U.S. Department of Energy through a KIPAC Fellowship at Stanford University and the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center. This project was also supported in its initial stages by the Swiss National Science Foundation and the Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics at the University of Chicago.

by Kelen Tuttle

-30-